Local picksNot sponsored • Community-guided

Best italian restaurants in Birmingham

We've picked 2 places in this category in Birmingham. These are Italian or Italian-style spots that our community goes back to again and again.

How we choose these places: steady recent reviews, Italian-style menus and service that makes people want to come back. Opening hours and menus can change – always double-check their website or socials before you go.

  • San Carlo (Temple Street)
    #1

    San Carlo (Temple Street)

    Flagship city-centre classic for seafood, pasta and white-tablecloth service.

    Hand-checkedCommunity favourite

    📍 4 Temple Street, Birmingham B2 5BN

    £££ClassicSeafoodSpecial occasions

    ☎️ 0121 633 0251

  • Tropea (Harborne)
    #2

    Tropea (Harborne)

    Neighbourhood Italian with seasonal small plates and fresh pasta in Harborne.

    Editor’s pickCommunity favourite

    📍 27 Lordswood Rd, Birmingham B17 9RP

    £££SeasonalFresh pastaNeighbourhood

    ☎️ 0121 427 9777

How we choose these places

Recent reviews

We look at the overall review pattern over recent months, not just one viral weekend.

Italian flavour first

We prioritise Italian or Italian-inspired menus, good ingredients and the right atmosphere.

Kept up to date

If a place closes, changes ownership or drops significantly, we remove it or update the guide.

Before you go

Booking tips

  • For weekends, book a few days in advance.
  • Mention allergies or special requirements when you book.
  • For outdoor tables or large groups, call ahead.

Price guide

Roughly: £ for casual spots, ££ for trattorias & pizzerias, £££ for special occasions.

More options

If you want to explore beyond our picks, you can always get a full overview on Google Maps. View on Google Maps.

Want to see other Italian categories in Birmingham?

Back to the Italian guide for Birmingham

Run an Italian business in this category in Birmingham?

The Birmingham directory helps Italians find Italian-run businesses in their area. We only highlight a limited number of places per category so people genuinely looking for Italian spots can find you.

Quick help

Not sure what you need?

Tell us your situation. We’ll point you to the right guide or service.

Clear. Bilingual. Step-by-step.