Best italian restaurants in Birmingham
We've picked 2 places in this category in Birmingham. These are Italian or Italian-style spots that our community goes back to again and again.
How we choose these places: steady recent reviews, Italian-style menus and service that makes people want to come back. Opening hours and menus can change – always double-check their website or socials before you go.
#1View full listingSan Carlo (Temple Street)
Flagship city-centre classic for seafood, pasta and white-tablecloth service.
Hand-checkedCommunity favourite
#2View full listingTropea (Harborne)
Neighbourhood Italian with seasonal small plates and fresh pasta in Harborne.
Editor’s pickCommunity favourite
Italian restaurants in Birmingham
Birmingham's Italian restaurant scene features both established names and exciting newcomers. San Carlo on Temple Street is the flagship of the well-known restaurant group — a grand city-centre Italian with excellent seafood and classic cooking. Tropea in Harborne brings a more contemporary, seasonal approach to Italian food in a neighbourhood setting. Together they represent the range of Italian dining available in England's second city.
Practical tips
- San Carlo is close to New Street station — walkable in 5 minutes.
- Tropea in Harborne is about 20 minutes from the city centre by bus or car.
- Book both restaurants in advance for weekend evenings.
Frequently asked questions
- What is the best Italian restaurant in Birmingham?
- San Carlo on Temple Street is the top choice for classic Italian dining in Birmingham — white tablecloths, excellent seafood and a grand setting. Tropea in Harborne is the pick for more contemporary, seasonal Italian cooking in a neighbourhood atmosphere.
Want to see other Italian categories in Birmingham?
Back to the Italian guide for BirminghamRun an Italian business in this category in Birmingham?
The Birmingham directory helps Italians find Italian-run businesses in their area. We only highlight a limited number of places per category so people genuinely looking for Italian spots can find you.