Pantry • Extra virgin olive oil • UK
Italian Extra Virgin Olive Oil in the UK9 Bottles You Can Trust
How to pick good Italian olive oil in the UK without wasting money: one everyday bottle, one finishing bottle, plus a few bulk-tin options if you cook a lot.
Get the Italian olive oil cheat sheet (PDF) + one email a month with Italian-in-the-UK tips.
Zero spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
UK-available only
Oils you can actually buy on Amazon UK or from major UK sellers — no impossible-to-find brands.
Label decoding
We break down what EVOO, cold-pressed, DOP, IGP and blends really mean in practice.
2-bottle strategy
One solid everyday bottle for cooking and one better bottle for finishing — max flavour, less waste.
TL;DR — a simple olive oil plan for UK kitchens
1) One everyday bottle Pick a decent extra virgin olive oil in a dark bottle for frying, roasting and everyday cooking. It doesn’t need to be fancy, just reliable.
2) One finishing bottle Choose a more fragrant, peppery EVOO to drizzle raw over salads, bread, soups and finished pasta.
3) Protect oil from light & heat Store it in the dark, away from the hob, close the cap tightly: treat good oil like wine, not like cheap vegetable oil.
Want a printable one-pager with the 2-bottle strategy, storage tips and brand list?
What does EVOO actually mean?
EVOO stands for Extra Virgin Olive Oil. It’s the highest common grade of olive oil and the one that makes sense to use if you care about flavour and health.
- It’s made only from olives — no blends with other vegetable oils.
- It has very low free acidity (max 0.8%), which signals healthy olives and good processing.
- It’s produced by mechanical means only (no solvents) and usually labelled as “cold-pressed”.
- If a bottle doesn’t clearly say “extra virgin”, it’s probably a more refined, flatter-tasting oil.
How to spot good extra virgin olive oil (even online)
You don’t need to be an oil sommelier: a few label clues and a couple of kitchen tests are enough.
| Signal | What to look for | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Bottle or tin | Dark glass or metal tin, not clear plastic | Shields oil from light and heat, slows rancidity. |
| Origin | “100% Italian” or a clear DOP/IGP region | Traceable origin usually means better quality control. |
| Dates | Best-before date and, ideally, harvest year | Very old oil loses aroma and tastes flat. |
| Taste | A little peppery tickle and slight bitterness | That’s polyphenols: it’s normal and a good sign. |
There’s no single perfect oil for everyone: test 1–2 different bottles and keep the one you genuinely enjoy.
Which olive oil to use where (hob, oven, finishing)
Instead of 6 half-used bottles, keep 2–3 with a clear job.
| Oil type | Best use | Quick examples |
|---|---|---|
| Everyday EVOO | Sautéing, roasting, pan-cooking, marinades | Roast veg, tomato pasta, chickpeas in the pan. |
| Finishing EVOO | Drizzling over hot and cold dishes | Bruschetta, salads, soups, grilled meat/fish. |
| Big tins (3–5L) | If you cook often for several people | Stews, oven trays, everyday pasta. |
| Neutral oil | Deep frying, sweet baking | Chips, cakes when you don’t want to use EVOO. |
The 2-bottle strategy: the minimum that actually works
If you rent, share a kitchen or have limited space, this combo covers 90% of what you cook.
- Step 1 — pick your base oil Choose a simple Italian or Mediterranean-blend EVOO in a dark 750ml–1L bottle that isn’t the very cheapest, but still good value.
- Step 2 — pick your finishing oil Add a smaller, more aromatic bottle (DOP/IGP or single-region) that you only use raw.
- Step 3 — decide where it lives Keep both bottles in a cupboard near the hob but not above it. If you buy a big tin, decant into smaller dark bottles.
Tip: if you share a kitchen, label your finishing bottle with your name. It’s cheaper than most ‘gourmet sauces’ but upgrades everything.
How to store olive oil (and spot when it’s gone bad)
- Keep away from hob, oven and radiators: heat is the enemy.
- Store in a cupboard or pantry, not on a sunny windowsill.
- Close the cap properly: oxygen speeds up oxidation.
- If oil smells like wax, cardboard or tastes totally flat, it’s likely rancid.
Your Italian olive oil mini kit (UK version)
Indicative links to help you choose. Some links are Amazon affiliate and may earn us a small commission at no extra cost to you.
1) Everyday EVOO
- 750ml–1L dark glass bottle or tin.
- Italian or Mediterranean blend, medium flavour (not too intense).
- Perfect for pasta, veg and everyday cooking.
2) Finishing EVOO
- Smaller bottle (500ml or less) but higher quality.
- Clear origin (e.g. Sicily, Puglia, Tuscany) or DOP/IGP label.
- Use only raw on bread, salads, soups.
3) Big tin (if you cook a lot)
- 3–5L metal tin kept in a cool, dark cupboard.
- Decant into 1–2 smaller dark glass bottles.
- Makes sense only if you cook a lot or share purchases.
What this kit gives you
- One oil that’s always fine to cook with.
- One special oil that makes bread, salads and soups taste Italian.
- Less waste: you buy on purpose and store properly.
Affiliate note: some links may be Amazon affiliate links. You don’t pay more; they help keep these guides free.
FAQ — Italian olive oil, UK edition
Does it have to be Italian to be good?
Can I fry with extra virgin olive oil?
How long does a bottle last after opening?
Is the cheap supermarket EVOO OK?
Related reads
- Italian Pantry Essentials (UK) →
- Tiny UK Kitchen, Big Italian Flavour →
- Aperitivo at Home: Snacks & Glasses →
Some links may earn us a small commission at no extra cost to you. It helps keep the community guides free.
Download the Italian olive oil cheat sheet (PDF)
A one-page overview of the 2-bottle strategy, storage tips, label notes and space to write down your favourite brands.